• Foley

    Insane designs! i love the winner!

  • http://twitter.com/PanPanmusic Pan Pan

    Cool designs. I’m digging the hair and planet looking design.

  • http://twitter.com/psyOPs_ psy/OPs

    wow everyone really does have different taste.

    #1 and #3 look great to me, can’t stand any of the others.

  • http://twitter.com/EoghainCarroll Eoghain

    Great competition mitch, looking forward to entering something into the next one now. I was sorry to read some of the negative comments below but I would say you ran the competition fairly. Not everyone has a massive following of people willing to like and share their work. Creativity should not be a popularity contest but should come down to quality of the work produced and I think you did a good job at keeping things fair

  • Anonymous

    Hi Mitch, good day. Greetings DJTT team

    Sincerely selection committee “Top Billin ‘” Midi Fighter Spectra design contest.

    However, I appreciate the opportunity to participate in the contest. I would like to show my opinion of my applicable, the evaluation criterion, if I may.

    Certainly I must say I am disappointed by the verdict resolved to conceive contest winners to win a MIDI Fighter Spectra.

    First, why did not respect at all the rules originally raised, where the winner was to be chosen by the highest number of “likes”. This does not take into account at all. Clearly this affects me because I was the person with more “likes”. While I understand the contests have a purpose and that is to promote a product or a brand in exchange for some benefit or service (although everyone can have their motivations). Well, I think I accomplished that goal quite well. All those “likes”, I gather by a large advocacy, sending personal messages to all my contacts: family and friends (many of them professional musicians) speaking of the competition and the product. I find it unfortunate that there is nothing heavy on the number of “likes” on the evaluation criterion being that this was the first rule of the contest. Now I have over 144 contacts who supported me, who were involved, who were following the count and now expected a favorable response. I will have to say: thank you very much for supporting me but, it did not help, because the original rules were not respected :-( and that even now with the chance of five possible winners, nor with that served as support. I leave them with a bad taste in their mouth, not to mention your server.

    Finally what disappoints me most is, not only that, returned to change the rules of competition by adding an additional winner, but, the winner picked apart for a design that is almost the copy or very, very similar to my third admission :-3 (just as mine with a touch of style history: “Joy Division”) entered two days before the announced design in the list of winners.

    After that I have little or no desire to participate in another event sponsored by DJTT if not with the bad experience can not be certain of the rules of the contest.

    I hope in some way are sensitive to this letter from a faithful follower since my previous comments on the blog and fb did not answer.

    Well that’s my thought on the situation.
    No more for now.

    Atte.

    Mik-e

    • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

      Mik-e, thanks for your comment, and your e-mail. However unfortunate you find it, the rules were changed within the first 3 days of the contest… which meant you then knew that continuing to garner “likes” was somewhat pointless. It was expressly written in the very few guidelines the contest had – “DJTT reserves the right to disqualify and delete any entries not following the rules and also the right to change the contest rules at any given time without notice.” This allowed the contest to be more fair for everyone… yourself included. I understand your frustration, but not everyone can win. There is a new contest going on right now, give that one a try!

      • Anonymous

        Well Mitch thanks for your answer, it is clear that you reserve the right to change the rules. But sorry, to me is not fair. It is as if one enters a 20k marathon and end up rewarding the best dress, ups sorry changed the rules. It is clear that several competed by the “likes”. The thing that keeps bothering me is that the final design continues to look to me like a copy of my last admission. Actually I have no desire to participate again in any contest that has to do with DJTT nor claim the prize of 25 dollars, I declined. I have no trust. Seeketh another gear meet my needs.

        Thanks for your attention.

        Have a nice day.

        • croyyy

          Wow someones butthurt

        • http://www.facebook.com/josiah.robins Josiah Robins

          I mean if you don’t want to use that $25 I could (and would) use it ;)

        • 32digits

          The like-contest was unfair from the start because someone who starts collecting likes from day 1 will have more than someone who enters last day(s)..

          You put more time in getting likes than in your design… I think you started with the wrong idea.

          and if you think your last entry was copied, honestly I don’t -it looks a million times better-, you should be proud they won.

  • Fugi

    I didn’t like number 3 until I saw it in the wood. Now it’s my favorite. Great job.

  • dfectiv

    oh man im happy I made it to one of the favorite designs, however what am I ever gonna do with a $25 off a midi fighter spectra? Im kinda broke so I couldnt even afford even half the price :))

    • doclvly

      send it this way. Ill steal a purse if I have to. (Kidding)

  • Thejone

    Wow! Really nice work!

  • Stewe

    Awesome! #6 looks super cool.

  • Ferreira

    that sucks!!!but, rules can be changed anytime here so :)
    congrats

  • http://www.facebook.com/steveteeps Steve Teeple

    The egyptian/hieroglyphs one is so killer! Curious on what the colors will be for that one.

    • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

      The colors will be up to you, it will become a normal top option in the configuration window.

  • 32digits

    2+6 best, because they didn’t use vectors and they are Godlike

    • Fugi

      What do you mean but didn’t use vectors? They have to be a vector file to meet the required output.

    • Doclvly

      And how are you sure the didn’t use “vectors”. You do know that everyone of these entries could have been made with vectors, and probably were.

      • Dee

        My whole design was in fact “vector” But was a vector that i created using my own style, When i sent my design to Mitch i gave him the raw A.I. File so if there had of been any cheating he would have been able to notice this from these files mate…..

    • mattmangrease

      I’m going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you mean PRE-MADE Vectors, as it was specifically a vector based competition… and using raster images would be absolutely abysmal for this type of work.

    • Fugi

      I’m pretty sure 6 wasn’t hand drawn. I am going to guess they were straight lines and then he used the the spiral tool and/or envelope distort.

      • 32digits

        yeah i meant pre-made vectors :)

  • ChipLoadup

    Why can’t I see the images?

    • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

      Still having an issue? Seems to working okay over here.

  • http://www.facebook.com/kane.wilkerson Kane Wilkerson

    1 2 and 3 were my favs, nice work everyone!

    • Dee

      Cheers Mate

  • http://www.facebook.com/tcowan.atl Timothy C. Cowan

    #4 is dope….my favorite

    • Doclvly

      Idk, I like the concept more than the execution. I’m sure it will look better on wood.

      • doclvly

        dam, it does look good. That mock up shut me up.

  • mattmangrease

    I LOVE number two!

  • djelevation

    Hats off to the winners. I actually like 4 of the 5 (I am not of fan of #1).

    I also realize design contest are super subjective, it all depends on personal style and taste, but a few of the top twenty leave me with a WTF feeling. Seriously? Poorly executed ninjas and that crappy alien-ish head with the DJTT logo kinda floating are just plain bad designs. I don’t like the bombs, but at least the art and concept is well executed…I know you guys pick based on originality usually but those are neither original nor well crafted and it bums me out when there were better choices to pull from.

    Overall though, the truly good submissions did win. Congrats!

    • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

      For slight clarification, just because it was an honorable mention doesn’t mean it was top 20 and vice versa.

      • djelevation

        My comment stands whether those were honorable mentions or the top twenty (which is kinda a different name for the same thing don’t you think). Several of the designs violate the guidelines of the contest with stroke weights, etc and some are just childish. Again, the ones that won deserve it (even if I don’t like #1).

        • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

          No, I don’t think they are the same. The entires which had violated the guidelines were naturally not in the top 20. The top 20 were the best designs that were marketable and efficiently re-produceable. Honorable mentions came after the winners had been selected, via staff members picking their particular favorite designs [regardless of marketability]. And as you noted – taste in designs is purely subjective.

          • http://twitter.com/pornstarjanitor stan kass

            #2, and #6, everything else up there looks like cheap cheesy garbage which detracts from the simple minimal purpose of the midi-fighter brand and aesthetic. Super surprised any but 2 & 6 were picked, they’re very ‘niche’ oriented (as is the midi fighter controller) but fuck, those other 4 are WEEEAAK.

          • Guest

            Its also hilarious that the graphic over the winning logo of the ‘olive leaves’ looks like a cheap ass copied/pasted vector.

          • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

            Hilarious is one word for it… However, creating the assets for the article, writing it, and managing the contest as a whole, on top of my normal already demanding job leads me to a different word. Thank you for the input though… I will try to make something better if I do it again!

          • http://www.djtechtools.com/ Mitch Manchild

            Thanks for the opinion Stan. To each his own is the only adequate response I can garner. We stand by our choices… the contest was for simple fun and cost nothing to anyone but us [my time in particular] – its impossible to please everyone, but I did my best.